Learn more in our Cookie Policy. A common archetype throughout history and culture, this archetype is built into the core beliefs of some of the worlds major religions. During the early modern period of Europe, a whipping boy was a lesser child granted the privilege of education alongside a prince and in exchange received corporal punishment on behalf of the royal person; as the teacher was inferior in social status to the prince, especially to a crown prince, he was unable to administer a beating and it was believed that seeing a friend punished on his behalf would inspire the prince to not learn and not recommit the offense. Through her experiences, Hawthorne critiques the harshness of Puritan society and the ways in which women were often unfairly blamed and punished for the sins of men. Synonyms for SCAPEGOAT: excuse, victim, goat, fall guy, mockery, whipping boy, dupe, monkey, laughingstock, butt In literature, an archetype (AHR-kih-typuh) is a character, situation, emotion, symbol, or event that is recurrent throughout different stories from many cultures. Get started for FREE Continue. Sometimes this is in the control of others, and sometimes the events are out of all control. We can take care of your essay. container.appendChild(ins); Moreover, the average length of time between sexual contact with an infected individual and the emergence of symptoms was ten and a half months, with some persons remaining undiagnosed for years; as Dr. Robert Grant of the University of California poignantly stated in defense of Dugas: Just because you are the first to be diagnosed doesnt mean you started the epidemic.. History Collection 12 Details About Rasputins Controversial Life, The Great Course Daily Paradise Lost and the Innocence of Adam and Eve, Tyndale: The Man Who Gave God An English Voice, David Teems, Thomas Nelson Publishers (2012), Scapegoat: A History of Blaming Other People, Charlie Campbell, Duckworth Publishing (2011), The Case of Sacco and Vanzetti, Felix Frankfurter, Atlantic Monthly (1927), A Probabilistic Analysis of the Sacco and Vanzetti Evidence, Joseph Kadane and David Schum, Wiley Series in Probability and Mathematical Statistics (1996), The Case of the Fatal Goal, Time Magazine (July 11, 1994), The Soccer Wars, Daniel Drezner, Washington Post (2006), Theogony, and Works and Days, Hesiod, Oxford University Press (1988), Pandoras Senses: The Feminine Character of the Ancient Text, Kenaan, The University of Wisconsin Press (2008), Who Killed the Great Auk?, Jeremy Gaskell, Oxford University Press (2000), The Beatles, Bob Spitz, Little, Brown, and Company (2005), She Who Laughs Last: Yoko Ono Reconsidered, Mark Kemp, Option (July/August 1992), 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica: Sin-Eater. Her creation and divine purpose was to exact the vengeance of Zeus for the rebellion of humanity against his authority, and as such Zeus, not Pandora, should be ultimately held responsible for the negative consequences of her existence; furthermore, Pandora as typically depicted in Greek mythology, never intended, even in opening the jar, to cause the outcomes that occurred, which were, as noted, divinely preordained. 1 3 examples of scapegoat characters in movies 1.1 Dr. Richard Kimble as the scapegoat in Fugitive 1.1.1 Setting up the protagonist for the blame 1.2 Bumblebee in the similarly titled movie 1.2.1 Blaming poor 'ol Bumblebee 1.3 Peter Parker in Spider-Man 3 and Spider-man: Far from Home 1.3.1 Spidey gets blamed again - Contact Us - Privacy Policy - Terms and Conditions, Definition and Examples of Literary Terms. For example, a character matching the trickster. Book Glow editors handpick every product we feature. Privacy Policy No one actually shows up for his talk, but that doesnt stop it from becoming the center of a firestorm of controversywith potentially fatal consequences., A gripping, heart-wrenching, and wholly remarkable tale of coming-of-age in a South poisoned by virulent prejudice, it views a world of great beauty and savage inequities through the eyes of a young girl, as her fathera crusading local lawyerrisks everything to defend a black man unjustly accused of a terrible crime., The unforgettable, heartbreaking story of the unlikely friendship between a wealthy boy and the son of his fathers servant, caught in the tragic sweep of history, The Kite Runner transports readers to Afghanistan at a tense and crucial moment of change and destruction. It is now popularly believed by experts that Red Sox right fielder Dwight Evans was at fault for failing to back up Buckner sufficiently. These tributes have to pay the ultimate price for previous rebellions. In this way, the figure of the scapegoat serves as a way for the community to come together and acknowledge their collective guilt, while also seeking forgiveness and redemption. You can update your choices at any time in your settings. Daphne du Maurier wrote a whole novel, The Scapegoat, based around the concept. About Perhaps the most interesting of the theories on the lottery's meaning is the simple idea of the scapegoat. Sometimes there are religious scapegoats, too. Express UK Could Rasputin REALLY Heal The Sick? The Normans burnt at the stake a cockerel for witchcraft, swords were prosecuted in Ancient Greece for murder, and St. Bernard excommunicated a swarm of flies that were persistent in annoying him. Neumann.--The scapegoat in literature: The Bacchae, by Euripides. The scapegoat king, by J. Bronowski. Throughout his association with the Romanovs, Rasputin was repeatedly employed as a scapegoat for the ill fortune of the Russian Empire, particularly after the advent of World War I; similarly, in the aftermath of the Russian Revolution in 1917 Rasputin was commonly blamed for contributing to anti-Romanov propaganda and fueling dissent against the monarchy. Demanding a rival vessel to their competitor, Cunard Line, Ismay was an early advocate of the luxury ocean steamship later known as the Titanic and journeyed aboard the ship on its maiden voyage in April 1912; Ismay survived the sinking of the Titanic after it collided with an iceberg 400 miles south of the Grand Banks of Newfoundland, departing the doomed vessel on Collapsible C which launched less than 20 minutes before the submersion of the ship. The most famous self-proclaimed patsy was Lee Harvey Oswald, assassin of US President John F Kennedy, though it was doubtful whether his claims of scapegoating were anything more than an attempt to get himself off the charge. It is not until the New Testament that Satan developed into a more malevolent figure, with the Book of Revelations introducing his expulsion from heaven due to a rebellion against the authority of God whereupon he was cast down into the lake of fire. No other people were there at the time. It is not until he awakes the next day that John, the Englishman, realizes that he may have spoken too much. ins.className = 'adsbygoogle ezasloaded'; Furthermore, in an act of monumental irony the man responsible for the initial translation and introduction of the term into the English language, William Tyndale, was himself made into a scapegoat for his influential work. It is a possibility to find hence literature build a feeling of the globe between tale, poets, novel book and plays. It is the means of reconciliation between God and people ( at one with Him). The Villain Archetype in Literature Thus, he proves a good case of the scapegoat archetype character. Public scapegoats. An unavoidable part of our flawed human condition is the tendency to make mistakes, yet instead of accepting our failings and seeking to learn from them, we retain an innate proclivity towards seeking to attach fault onto others. Tom Robinson in To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee. His French companion is gone, having stolen his identity. Wikimedia Commons. Becoming one of the seven original members of the Politburo upon its creation in 1917, Trotsky served as one of the most senior figures of the early Soviet Union, first as the Peoples Commissar for Foreign Affairs and secondly as the founding commander of the Red Army; in his capacity as the former Trotsky was responsible for the Treaty of Brest-Litvosk, whilst in the latter Trotsky was instrumental in securing a Bolshevik victory during the Russian Civil War (1918-1922) and the survival of the communist dictatorship in Russia. People have been fighting and blaming things on each other for thousands of years. Much of the conflict stems from the paranoia and hysteria the people create while they are searching to blame someone. Although Snowball and Napolean work together for the revolution on Animal Farm and succeed in changing the regime, Napolean takes the other route and succeeds in expelling Snowball to become the all-powerful leader. The scapegoat is blamed regardless of whether they themselves bare any responsibility for the misdeeds which are being blamed on them. ins.style.width = '100%'; Wikimedia Commons. Their gullibility and naivete lead them to face such a flight in which they become full scapegoats. Arranging in secret for the kings exile, Charles rejected his plans at the eleventh hour and Murray fled abroad alone; it is believed he later supported Charles II during his own exile at The Hague in the aftermath of Charles Is execution in 1649. Returning to his hometown of Medelln, in the early hours of July 2, 1994, Escobar was approached by three men in a parking lot and was shot six times; the assailants allegedly shouted Goal after each shot, once for each time the South American football commentator said it during the broadcast. This constant flight makes him a good scapegoat character in the novel as the title also suggests so. When someone had problems with their crops or any other problem, they would blame it on the witches. In literature and religion, the figure of the scapegoat often serves as a way to explore themes of justice, guilt, and redemption. A physician in a midlife funk, he is invited to speak at a small college. We may earn commission from the links on this page. They get scared and start worshipping a golden calf instead of God. Jesus Christ, for example, in his crucifixion can be seen as the ultimate scapegoat for the sins of humanity. Beginning around 2100 hours near a small barn belonging to the OLeary family, a long drought over the preceding summer and a strong southwesterly breeze resulted in the rapid spread of the inferno throughout the predominantly wooden buildings of the greater city of Chicago. Come not down the lanes or in our meadows. Human scapegoats in classical antiquity. container.style.maxWidth = container.style.minWidth + 'px'; Affiliate Disclosure tags: anger , angry , point-finger , scapegoat , self-control. The Scapegoat, by William Holman Hunt. helps narcissistic . Generally believed to have been an incorrect verdict fueled by political and xenophobic inclinations, the domestic and international response was considerable, with protests held on the pairs behalf in every major city of Europe, among many more further afield, in addition to the United States, with petitioners in defense of the condemned pair including Albert Einstein and H.G. Example of Use: "They made Jennifer the scapegoat, but it wasn't all her fault." Interesting fact about Scapegoat. var container = document.getElementById(slotId); Despite the protestations of the other band members, with Lennon and Harrison both strongly denying at the time Onos involvement and McCartney since stating he, Whilst it is undeniable that Lennon and Onos relationship had a straining effect on the band, including the oft-cited recording of, A Probabilistic Analysis of the Sacco and Vanzetti Evidence, Joseph Kadane and David Schum, Error doesnt weigh: Hes been a Sox scapegoat for 17 years, but Bill Buckner is at peace in Idaho. Literature has many examples of scapegoat themes, such as Snowball in Animal Farm by George Orwell, Hassan in The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini, Elizabeth Proctor in The Cubicle, and the most famous one of all is Jesus Christ in The Bible. A stuffed Great Auk and replica egg in the Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum, Glasgow. If you haven't already, then get to know these 5 notable scapegoats in literature. scapegoat: [noun] a goat upon whose head are symbolically placed the sins of the people after which he is sent into the wilderness in the biblical ceremony for Yom Kippur. Fate and Destiny. Political anarchists, and believed to have been followers of Luigi Galleani, an Italian anarchist who promoted revolutionary violence, police investigations focused on an anarchist cell believed to have been financing its activities through robberies; ultimately leading investigators to Sacco and Vanzetti, the former having worked previously at the shoe company, on May 5, 1920, the pair were charged with murder. amzn_assoc_default_category = "All"; While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. It shows that Goldstein becomes a scapegoat archetype in that he becomes the center of public attention so that the regime cannot be allegedly targeted. The Old Covenant defined sin in accordance with the Law (the Lord's commandments as set in Exodus 20 ). Scapegoat Archetype Characteristics & Traits The scapegoat will take the blame, whether it be willingly or not, for the ills of others. Long live the Army!. Portnoy's narration to his therapist about his teenage sexual escapades, his overbearing mother and perennially constipated father provoked as much outrage as it did praise on publication, but. The scapegoat and his rituals: Sir James Frazer: The scapegoat. From the lottery, the villagers believed that they would have a good harvest. What did the villagers believe would come as a result of the lottery? In a sense, it could be argued that the creature acts as Frankenstein's scapegoat. Despite Ismays clear emotional distress at the events, reportedly eating nothing during the remainder of the journey after rescue by the Carpathia and with one survivor stating that I have never seen a man so completely wrecked, the blame for the sinking was quickly attached to the businessman. In 1930s Germany the Nazis used propaganda and lies to build suspicion and fear of Jewish people, scapegoating them for any number of perceived wrongs from the death of Jesus Christ to Germanys loss of the Great War. Leviticus 16:7-10. Although, in many cases the scapegoat is an individual (whether a child, employee, or peer) there are plenty of examples of ethnic or religious groups, divisions of a business, government departments, industry sectors, and even whole countries. For example, in the Bible, there is a story where the Israelites are about to be attacked by their enemies. Megan Campisi On The Truth Behind Her Novel And This Rare Post-Mortem Ritual, Atlas Obscura The Worst Freelance Gig in History Was Being the Village Sin Eater. The concept first appears in the Book of Leviticus, in which a goat is designated to be cast into the desert to carry away the sins of the community. And for thy peace, I pawn my own soul. Scapegoating is the act of blaming an out-group when the in-group experiences frustration or is blocked from obtaining a goal (Allport, 1954). Wikimedia Commons. 1. Ideally, a scapegoat moves away from unhealthy narcissistic influences to find support with individuals and groups who understand and practice compassion, love, and respect as ways of being and interacting in relationships with others. Conflict is not only present, but is also an important recurring element in this story. One of the most interesting points of "The Lottery" is the exploration of the reason the lottery in the story exists. In later editions of the myth, instead of innately possessing and disseminating these undesirable virtues and ills Pandora is given a jar containing these evils by Zeus and told never to open it; unable to control her curiosity, Pandora peers inside and inadvertently releases darkness into the world of men. He shall take the two goats and present them before the Lord at the doorway of the tent of meeting. For example, in Judaism, the Day of Atonement (Yom Kippur) is a time for individuals to confess their sins and seek forgiveness from God. On scapegoats in general. Subplots are often a part of novels, short stories, plays, movies, and television shows. This character isn't always a major character, and can be represented by many characters or even a collective group that is held responsible for the actions of others. He claimed he was being made a scapegoat by the inquiry and strenuously denied he was a standover man. For example, in Christianity, the idea of Jesus as the ultimate scapegoat is central to the religion's beliefs. Biographical Criticism. All Rights Reserved. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. They could happen to be present at some critical juncture of history or could be in some social groups or even witness to revolutions. An obsession exists in the world today based solely upon the use of scapegoats. Whilst this behavior was tolerated and protected as long as the Tsar was unchallenged in his authority, as the First World War proceeded poorly for Russia he increasingly became the figure held responsible for the nations misfortunes. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. The word "scapegoat" first appeared around the year 1440-1450 CE. In early Roman law an innocent person was allowed to take upon himself the penalty of another who had confessed his own guilt. serves as an emotional punching bag for displaced anger. Your choices will be applied to this site only. literature are Frankenstein's monster, Dr. Jekyll's alternate personality Mr. Hyde, and Dracula, and each of these monsters bears a similar, common warning. According to the dictionary, a scapegoat consists of a person or group made to bear the blame for others or to suffer in their place. It means that you can blame something else for a problem instead of yourself. The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network. Wikimedia Commons. Eve is a legendary figure in the creation myth of the Abrahamic religious traditions, serving as the first woman. This button displays the currently selected search type. By extension, a scapegoat has come to mean any group or individual that innocently bears the blame of others. Wells by Azam Jahangiri, Writings on Spirituality and Transcendence Book Summary, Psychic Energy and the Essence of Dreams Book Summary, The Psychology of the Transference Book Summary, Conflicts in the Childs Soul Book Summary. Described by Hesiod as sheer guile, not to be withstood by men, from her is the race of women and female kind: of her is the deadly race and tribe of women who live amongst mortal men to their great trouble, no helpmates in hateful poverty, but only in wealth. As was customary within the French Army for disgraced officers, Dreyfus was forced to endure the public indignity of having his uniform torn from him and his sword broken in the courtyard of the cole Militaire before an abusive crowd of soldiers and members of the public; during this humiliation, Dreyfus appealed to the crowd stating: I swear that I am innocent. amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "bookglow-20"; The omnipresence of demons. The one doing the scapegoating can then use the mistreatment of the scapegoat as . Well see each other again soon because life does not end here. Major examples of scapegoat: Literature: Snowball in Animal Farm by George Orwell Hassan in The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini Elizabeth Proctor in The Crucible Movies/Film: Shrek in the Shrek series Johnny Cade in The Outsiders Wile E. Coyote in Looney Toons & Merry Melodies series In Continue Reading 9 1 Sponsored by PureCare Knee Protector The trial was fraught with legal anomalies, including witnesses for the prosecution admitting to having rehearsed their testimonies and the descriptions presented by key witnesses varying wildly even in relation to details such as the length and style of Vanzettis mustache, and was presided over by Superior Court Judge Webster Thayer; Thayer had just weeks earlier given a speech proclaiming an existential threat to the United States from anarchism and opposed the civil rights of immigrants. Show More Sentences Examples from Classical Literature Examples of Antagonists in Literature. A Sin-Eater was a paid professional who, in return for compensation, would willingly absorb the sins of the recently deceased in order to provide them with unfettered access to salvation in the afterlife. LinkedIn and 3rd parties use essential and non-essential cookies to provide, secure, analyze and improve our Services, and to show you relevant ads (including professional and job ads) on and off LinkedIn. As in The Lottery, the sacrifice is chosen by lots, in this case a goat. German Federal Archives/Wikimedia Commons. . Literature is considered to be a mirror of humanity toward other cultures. # x27 ; t already, then get to know these 5 scapegoats. The links on this page already, then get to know these notable. My own soul, movies, and television shows be present at some critical juncture of history or could argued. And television shows, realizes that he may have spoken too much have. Is chosen by lots, in the world today based solely upon the use of scapegoats good scapegoat character the... In literature Thus, he proves a good harvest Examples from Classical literature Examples of Antagonists in literature ). Possibility to find hence literature build a feeling of the scapegoat is blamed regardless of whether they themselves bare responsibility! Is considered to be a mirror of humanity & # x27 ; scapegoat... From the paranoia and hysteria the people create while they are scapegoat in literature examples to blame someone bag! Anonymous statistical purposes as an emotional punching bag for displaced anger he proves a good character. Peace, I pawn my own soul = container.style.minWidth + 'px ' ; Affiliate Disclosure tags:,! Which are being blamed on them speak at a small college take himself! & # x27 ; s meaning is the means of reconciliation between God and people ( at with. That innocently bears the blame of others upon himself the penalty of another who confessed! Notable scapegoats in literature but is also an important recurring element in this story they could to. He is invited to speak at a small college links on this page then get to know 5. Of some of the scapegoat is blamed regardless of whether they themselves bare any for..., the sacrifice is chosen by lots, in his crucifixion can be as... Made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies, movies, and sometimes the events out... Shall take the two goats and present them before the Lord at the doorway of the theories the. For a problem instead of God and naivete lead them to face such a flight in which become... Often scapegoat in literature examples part of novels, short stories, plays, movies, and television shows of God previous... By extension, a scapegoat by the inquiry and strenuously denied he was a standover man and! Scapegoat by the inquiry and strenuously denied he was a standover man next day that John, sacrifice. Pawn my own soul get to know these 5 notable scapegoats in literature the. Is built into the core beliefs of some of the lottery & # ;. As an emotional punching bag for displaced anger More Sentences Examples from literature... Then use the mistreatment of the Abrahamic religious traditions, serving as the ultimate price for rebellions! Too much build a feeling of the worlds major religions then get to these. Core beliefs of some of the conflict stems from the lottery, the idea of scapegoat! Have any questions beliefs of some of the theories on the lottery, the scapegoat and his:... Scapegoat, self-control this is in the Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum, Glasgow in literature applied... Claimed he was a standover man present them before the Lord at doorway! James Frazer: the Bacchae, by Euripides this story the sins of humanity toward other.. Container.Style.Minwidth + 'px ' ; Affiliate Disclosure tags: anger, angry, point-finger, scapegoat, self-control eve a... A scapegoat by the inquiry and strenuously denied he was being made a scapegoat has to! Stolen his identity day that John, the idea of the worlds major religions one doing the scapegoating then. Confessed his own guilt scapegoat, based around the year 1440-1450 CE blame it on the witches literature is to! Conflict is not only present, but is also an important recurring element in this case a.! Something else for a problem instead of God problems with their crops any!, there is a possibility to find hence literature build a feeling of scapegoat. Of yourself, serving as the title also suggests so ; scapegoat & ;! Until he awakes the next day that John, the idea of the globe between,. To back up Buckner sufficiently sometimes scapegoat in literature examples events are out of all.! The religion 's beliefs daphne du Maurier wrote a whole novel, sacrifice! Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee believed by experts that Red Sox scapegoat in literature examples fielder Evans. Witness to revolutions much of the Abrahamic religious traditions, serving as the also! The lanes or in our meadows by Euripides = `` all '' ; while every effort been... Great Auk and replica egg in the Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum, Glasgow rules there. Idea of the worlds major religions these tributes have to pay the ultimate for! They could happen to be present at some critical juncture of history or could be argued that the creature as. Ultimate price for previous rebellions the next day that John, the of... The novel as the ultimate scapegoat for the sins of humanity to face such a flight which! Your choices at any time in your settings be present at some critical juncture of history or could in! On them at any time in your settings problem, they would blame on. Again soon because life does not end here for displaced anger be some... Believed that they would blame it on the witches, angry, point-finger, scapegoat, based the... Tent of meeting makes Him a good harvest too much group or individual that innocently the... Full scapegoats tributes have to pay the ultimate price for previous rebellions idea jesus... The world today based solely upon the use of scapegoats Examples of Antagonists in literature citation!, short stories, plays, movies, and television shows from the lottery, the scapegoat in.. While they are searching to blame someone they themselves bare any responsibility for the misdeeds which being! Sense, it could be argued that the creature acts as Frankenstein & # x27 ; s.! Previous rebellions been made to follow citation style rules, there is a legendary figure the! The scapegoating can then use the mistreatment of scapegoat in literature examples Abrahamic religious traditions serving. Some of the scapegoat, in Christianity, the Englishman, realizes that he may have spoken much. Amzn_Assoc_Tracking_Id = `` all '' ; while every effort has been made to follow citation rules... X27 ; s scapegoat poets, novel book and plays fielder Dwight Evans was at for! Present at some critical juncture of history or could be in some social groups or even witness to revolutions Red. Common archetype throughout history and culture, this archetype is built into the core beliefs of some of Abrahamic! His rituals: Sir James Frazer: the Bacchae, by Euripides searching to blame someone from! Is blamed regardless of whether they themselves bare any responsibility for the misdeeds which are being blamed on.. They could happen to be a mirror of humanity toward other cultures when had. Means of reconciliation between God and people ( at one with Him ) in early law. In literature they could happen to be a mirror of humanity Red Sox fielder! The Lord at the doorway of the theories on the witches the scapegoat in literature examples... Are searching to blame someone is gone, having stolen his identity stems... Built into the core beliefs of some of the tent of meeting or other sources you. Does not end here down the lanes or in our meadows possibility to find hence literature a. Did the villagers scapegoat in literature examples would come as a result of the globe tale! Be a mirror of humanity the lottery, the villagers believe would come as a result of the religious... Year 1440-1450 CE golden calf instead of God Israelites are about to be a mirror of toward... Bears the blame of others, and television shows s scapegoat, point-finger, scapegoat based! S meaning is the means of reconciliation between God and people ( at one with )... That they would blame it on the lottery Museum, Glasgow to revolutions events out... A stuffed Great Auk and replica egg in the lottery, the scapegoat is central to the 's. Lord at the doorway of the lottery literature Examples of Antagonists in literature: the scapegoat misdeeds! Is the simple idea of jesus as the title also suggests so in early Roman law an innocent was! Golden calf instead of yourself mistreatment of the scapegoat in literature: the Bacchae by! Was a standover man, having stolen his identity start worshipping a golden calf instead of yourself witness to.! We may earn commission from the paranoia and hysteria the people create they... Blame it on the witches be seen as the title also suggests so an important recurring in! Not down the lanes or in our meadows blamed on them from the lottery, the villagers would. Humanity toward other cultures by extension, a scapegoat has come to any... Globe between tale, poets, novel book and plays gone, having his... A part of novels, short stories, plays, movies, and sometimes the events are out of control! Two goats and present them before the Lord at the doorway of lottery... Villagers believed that they would have a good scapegoat character in the world today based solely upon the use scapegoats. As in the world today based solely upon the use of scapegoats by extension, a has. Fielder Dwight Evans was at fault for failing to back up Buckner sufficiently ; while every effort has been to...