What started out as a challenge to bring awareness to the motor neuron disease ALS soon spiraled into a terrifying example of groupthink. Dr. Donelson Forsyth holds the Colonel Leo K. and Gaylee Thorsness Endowed Chair in Ethical Leadership in the Jepson School of Leadership at the University of Richmond. Lord of the Flies is a 1954 novel by British author William Golding. On December 2, 2001, energy giant Enron filed for bankruptcy. Group decision making: The potential for groupthink. Launching an offensive advertising campaign for a consumer product because employees dont articulate their dissent. Ken: Is there a way to propose a less onerous, but still comprehensive account? Kevin: Is this data accessible on the network, or is it data that resides within an individuals application? They were sure that the Japanese would see the obvious futility of entering a war with the US. . Beyond stereotyping, Kennedys administration thought itself untouchable. Under the auspices of Nurse Keith Coaching, Keith's passion is helping nurses and healthcare professionals create ultimate satisfaction in both their personal and professional lives. It marks a deterioration of mental efficiency, reality testing, and moral judgment that results from ingroup pressures (Janis, 1972, p. 9). We rely on the most current and reputable sources, which are cited in the text and listed at the bottom of each article. On the other hand, conformity is a process in which people change their own actions so they can fit in with a specific group. They simply went ahead and ran the ad. It spread like wildfire over social media and had millions of views within days. Janis identified a number of different "symptoms" that indicate groupthink.. Media accounts of the noncompliant groups suggest that the conditions that often cause groupthinksuch as high levels of cohesion and isolation, stress, strong conformity pressures, and directive but misinformed leadershipwere all in evidence as these groups grew in influence and intensity. Indeed, previous research has challenged Janis model. Then identify and celebrate moments of broad agreement. Space shuttle engineers knew about certain faulty parts before the take-off. Return to APA Journals Article Spotlight homepage. He is the former editor of the Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education. They can then frame a lack of final agreement as progress and so maintain morale and forward momentum. An often cited example of group think is the Challenger disaster. Groupthink is a process in which the motivation for consensus in a group causes poor decisionsmade by knowledgeable people. 2022 May 18. Ron: So, let me get this straight what transparency means is that the patient has access to every single point of access to his or her record. 2011;4(1):37-57. Patient-Oriented Research Competencies in Health (PORCH) for patients, healthcare providers, decision-makers and researchers: protocol of a scoping review. According to them, its a phenomenon where members of a group begin to think erroneously. Its been found that members with better jobs and education have a great amount of influence over lesser members and can persuade them to change their verdict. This group believed that it was possible to increase profits quarter after quarter. Assign at least one individual to take the role of the "devil's advocate.". This concept was first spoken about by social psychologist Irving Janis and journalist William H. Whyte. 2017;4(8):170193. doi:10.1098/rsos.170193. Here, the desire for group cohesion effectively drives out good decision-making and problem solving. House prices would continue to rise no matter what. It was only when the evidence became undeniable that these doctors reversed their claims. Literature search and article selection process. Groupthink is a common factor in bad decision-making and serious ethical breaches. A modern example of Groupthink is a politically incorrect marketing campaign, imagine a company seeking to launch a new marketing campaign for a consumer product. The .gov means its official. Groupthink has become a widely studied and accepted phenomenon. Groupthink can lead collective rationalization, lack of personal accountability and pressure to acquiesce. Kendra Cherry, MS, is an author and educational consultant focused on helping students learn about psychology. (Features & Stereotypes). When people in groups have diverse backgrounds and experiences, they are better able to bring different perspectives, information, and ideas to the table. Groupthink also tends to lead group members to perceive the group as inherently moral or right. When there are structural issues (such as group isolation and a lack of impartial, The suppression of individual opinions and creative thought can lead to inefficient. 236-271. They could either replace the host with Jay Leno or David Letterman. Researchers studied four virtual task forces that were set up to recommend a process to make Americans health care records electronic. MeSH Despite this, the Pearl Harbor command didnt actually believe that the Japanese would attack. When Ken uttered the word onerous it changed the direction of the conversation, because it attacked the usefulness of the status quo. This tendency to seek consensus above all else also means that group members may not adequately assess the potential risks and benefits of a decision. Early Hum Dev. These include: The suppression of individual opinions and creative thought can lead to inefficient problem-solving. 11 Examples of Groupthink. Diversity of ideas and can piggyback on others' ideas. Also, delaying agreements means one thing most group members dislike more and longer meetings! Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 73(2-3), pp. Despite this, group leaders within NASA choose to ignore these warnings. Alexander Downer Columnist. In case you dont know, this was an event where North Vietnamese ships attacked the U.S.S. and transmitted securely. Examples of groupthink in the workplace Groupthink doesn't happen in government and politics alone. Takes longer. An example of this is when a larger group of boys begins to victimize an overweight boy, culminating in his murder. Once President Kennedy came into power, the plan was immediately put into action. They also stereotyped their enemies, deeming them unable to make correct decisions. "Groups affected by groupthink ignore alternatives and tend to take irrational actions that dehumanize other groups" Social Psychologist Irving Janis (1972). The invasion ended up being an enormous failure, and people directly blamed the Kennedy administration. The phenomenon can have high costs. In addition, each of the four individuals trusts each other's judgment. Please enable it to take advantage of the complete set of features! These groups are tasked with developing consensus around new ideas, such as procedures, policies, products, or services. Other examples where decision-making is believed to be heavily influenced by groupthink include: In more everyday settings, researchers suggest that groupthink might play a part in decisions made by professionals in healthcare settings. Turner Joy. Medical, military, or political decisions, for example, can lead to unfortunate outcomes when they are impaired by the effects of groupthink. Gokar H. Groupthink principles and fundamentals in organizations. Assign specific roles to certain members of the group. This group might come to distrust and even inflict violence on outgroup members with different political views. Groupthink is a phenomenon that occurs when the desire for group consensus overrides people's common sense desire to present alternatives, critique a position, or express an unpopular opinion. When groups are tasked with coming to consensus on a course of action, agreement feels good it denotes progress and group belonging. My knowing who has accessed my records after the fact has no bearing on my ability to control who can have access and who cannot. (1982). And Ryan interpreted the audit system not allowing for patient control as onerous. Conformity can sometimes cause groupthink, but it isn't always the motivating factor. To avoid groupthink in your teams we recommend managers take the following three steps. Gatekeeping is the process of filtering messages. Group dynamics (2nd ed.). Doing this helps these types of groups make better decisions. This shows an incredible failure of critical thinking and decision-making. In many cases, people will set aside their own personal beliefs or adopt the opinion of the rest of the group. This group of girls (known as The Plastics) routinely engage in groupthink. What is groupthink? As we now know, the United States decision to ignore this critical information proved was an immense disaster. Groups are tempted to gravitate towards the status quo because they dont face a high cost if they fail. Look no further than the face in the mirror. He holds a PhD in education and has published over 20 articles in scholarly journals. These communications confirmed that an attack was imminent. In January 1986, the space shuttle Challenger exploded 73 seconds after liftoff, killing all seven astronauts aboard. Whoever still blindly supports such cruel and ineffective indoctrination is an obvious adherent to groupthink that absolutely endangers patients. People often find it hard to think and act independently in group situations. Forsyth, D. (1990). These doctors were obviously a victim of groupthink and refused to alter their claims despite growing evidence that cigarettes caused health issues. Consider allowing people to submit anonymous comments, suggestions, or opinions. Lunenburg FC. The reason given for this war was supposedly that Hussein was stockpiling WMDs. These include:. Ryan: I have a problem with the pure audit model. Thus, they failed to prepare for the bombing of Pearl Harbour, which claimed many lives. Treating new ideas as liminal (rather than literal) allowed members to relieve some of this pressure and enter into a transitional space where play and experimentation were encouraged. Members of this group believe they are geniuses when in fact, many have only average intelligence. The power of groupthink: Study shows why ideas spread in social networks. Within nursing, when a staff nurse questions a particular accepted practice, the most dangerous words to be spoken in response are, Well, thats the way weve always done it. In nursing, groupthink can keep nurses utilizing practices that are not evidence-based simply because change is too bothersome. Give people time to come up with their own ideas first. The company soon caved to social pressures, reversed its decision, and reverted back to the old Coke formula. Mob mentality, herd mentality, pack mentality, groupthink, or crowd psychology the concept has many names. Identifying the best individual can be challenging. Groupthink occurs when individuals in cohesive groups fail to consider alternative perspectives because they are motivated to reach a consensus which typically results in making less than desirable decisions. People in groups often make mistakes, not because they have been overcome by their emotions or have subpar intelligence but because group-level processes prevent members from accurately appraising information, identifying errors, and considering superior alternatives. (Features & Stereotypes), 10 Italian People Features & Stereotypes (What They Look Like), 10 Polish people Features, Characteristics and Stereotypes, What do Swedish People Look Like? What are some examples of groupthink in healthcare? There are four mutual fund managers - Jeffery, John, Jack, and Jane - who are each in charge of a mutual fund for Company A. To quell the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic, health authorities urged people to take easy-to-implement precautions, such as limiting social interactions, wearing a face covering, and vaccinating. The current analysis examined media descriptions of these antiquarantine groups to determine if these groups' divergent responses to a legally and medically warranted health initiative resulted from groupthink: the deterioration of judgment and rationality that sometimes occurs in groups. For example, these times have pitted group against group, race against race, sex against sex. Scholars have found that decision-making processes only sometimes define ultimate outcomes. The concept of "groupthink" was identified and in the 1970s by Yale psychologist Irving Janice and popularized as a reaction to the policies created by "the best and the brightest" that gave us the Bay of Pigs and the Vietnam War. Groupthink, a term coined by Irving Janis to depict premature consensus seeking in highly cohesive groups, is a theory that has been widely discussed in disciplines outside health care. Groupthink is most often associated with business, politics, and policymaking, but it also relates to the psychology of collective phobias and mass hysteria. In this experiment, Jones told students he was starting a fictional movement known as The Third Wave. He then took various beliefs held by the Nazi Party and passed these off as the aims of his movement. When organizations need to solve a problem, they often create a task force, selection panel, or steering/advisory committee. Groupthink is an important social theory that has been used to explain a number of real-life events, including some where groupthink has led to tragedy. In 2017, Kendall Jenner appeared in a highly controversial ad for Pepsi. Copyright 2023 Helpful Professor. It emerged from his effort to understand why knowledgeable political groups often made disastrous decisions (especially in foreign policy). Groupthink is a type of thinking when members of a group accept the group consensus uncritically. Group polarization leads to changing attitudes among individuals within the group. They ignored the dangers and negative feedback, blindly trusting the military advantage of the U.S. For example, a newspaper that decides to cover 12-15 stories a day from thousands of events and issues that potentially deserve attention. This site needs JavaScript to work properly. Forsyth, D. R. (2020). For example, prior studies have found that brainstorming results in fewer ideas rather than more, and hinders rather than helps productivity. So how can managers help their teams keepfresh ideas alive? Groupthink occurs when a group makes faulty or ineffective decisions for the sake of reaching a consensus. Weeks before the attack, hundreds of communications were intercepted from Japan. The Bay of Pigs Invasion As mentioned, the theory of groupthink was first spoken about by Yale psychologist Irving Janis. The purpose of this film was supposedly to start an international movement that would bring him to justice. PMC On the fifth day, Ron told students that they were going to watch a video. We call these liminal ideas while they may not be the final solution, they function as transitional placeholders that allow the group to think both concretely (i.e., drilling down on how the idea might work) and abstractly (i.e., developing agreement around the broader principle in question). Kendra Cherry, MS, is an author and educational consultant focused on helping students learn about psychology. Kramer, R. M. (1998). Ultimately, this advert probably happened due to ideological conformity created by political correctness. Pacific Grove, Calif: Brooks/Cole. Our website is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Its interesting to note how the community reached a consensus, based on almost no evidence. What actually happened was that an economic bubble steadily grew and eventually popped. Often times, the pressure to make a correct evaluation especially for experts can feel paralyzing when errors are costly. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Fuller S.R, & Aldag R.J. (1998). 2022;44(3):309-318. doi:10.1080/0142159X.2021.1987404. Before big decisions, leaders should hold a "second-chance" meeting where members have the opportunity to express any remaining doubts. Embrace conflict dont quell it in the interest of harmony. It tells the story of a group of boys stranded on an island during a fictional World War 3. The girls also believe that everything they do is right and discard their personal opinions. It achieves the objectives and goals of the group, even if the means and end to it are irrational and harmful. Maddox and U.S.S.C. According to psychologist Irving Janis, groupthink is "a deterioration of mental efficiency, reality testing, and moral judgment that . In addition to this, the Coca-Cola company also received large amounts of negative press and attention. We call these moments triggers, because they kick start the group process of embracing new and different approaches. Thankfully, there are a lot of ways to avoid groupthink. 2020 Dec;213 Suppl 11:S3-S32.e1. Kevin: Say a patient gives Dr. Jones permission to view and incorporate their information. The country may eventually begin to think as a collective whole that they are more powerful than they are and may make a fatal mistake like going to war with a larger and more powerful nation. Initially, the leader of the group should avoid stating their opinions or preferences when assigning tasks. Essentially, a lack of conflict or opposing viewpoints leads to poor decisions. The negative effects of these faulty decisions eventually began to accumulate and eventually led to the collapse of the company. Groupthink is defined as the practice of approaching issues as matters to be dealt with by consensus of a group rather than by individuals acting independently. Actively seek and value diversity on teams to include age, cultural, educationaland ideas. A number of factors can influence this psychological phenomenon. They subscribe to views/decisions they disagree with. All Rights Reserved. Groupthink: A Study in Self Delusion, by Mr Christopher Booker. However, American psychologist Irving Janis introduced the comprehensive theory of groupthink in 1972. This was a planned invasion of Cuba initially drawn up by the Eisenhower administration. Imagine that someone proposes an idea that you think is quite poor. While some may readily embrace groupthink as the modus operandi of American healthcare, others push back against such ignorance with the power of the creative mind. Despite all evidence to the contrary, the American auto industry stubbornly clung to this belief, only changing their views after losing significant market share to Japanese car manufacturers. In Orwells aforementioned Nineteen Eighty-Four, ignorance is bliss is a motto widely disseminated by the authoritarian regime ruling that frightening (yet strangely familiar) fictional country imagined by the author following the defeat of the fascist regimes of the first half of the century. Keywords: Some people actually believe that this organization is a scam. In 2003, a multi-country coalition chose to invade Iraq and topple Saddam Hussein. Here are four biases that commonly surface in medicine. Two well-known examples of Groupthink in action are . Heres another famous example of groupthink. For example, research shows that groups with seven or more members are more susceptible to confirmation bias. Not all poor group decisions result from groupthink. These groups are highly prone to groupthink quick agreement around status quo solutions with little discussion or deliberation. Year: 2011. Multi-Disciplinary Meetings (MDM) in which medical and allied health care professionals consider relevant options and collaboratively arrive at a decision regarding diagnosis, prognosis or treatment for a patient have been found to lead to better decisions than those made by sole physicians (Lamb et al., Citation 2011a; Ruhstaller, Roe, Thrlimann, & Nicoll, Citation 2006). When there is a high degree of cohesiveness. Organizational Tonypandy: Lessons from a Quarter Century of the Groupthink Phenomenon. One year on from Russian President Vladimir Putin's disastrous decision to invade Ukraine, the Western liberal democracies have reason to be . According to historical sources, a small group of teenage girls (led by a 17-year-old called Elizabeth Hubbard) instigated the trials when they began accusing others of witchcraft. Only when the evidence became undeniable that these doctors reversed their claims despite growing evidence that cigarettes caused issues. Care records electronic to certain members of a group causes poor decisionsmade by knowledgeable people,! Towards the status quo because they dont face a high cost if they fail their claims the day... The girls also believe that this organization is a process in which the motivation for consensus in a highly ad... Such cruel and ineffective indoctrination is an author and educational consultant focused on helping students learn about psychology despite evidence. 2, 2001, energy giant Enron filed for bankruptcy how the community a. Irrational and harmful examples of groupthink in healthcare eventually began to accumulate and eventually popped results in fewer rather... Hussein was stockpiling WMDs only sometimes define ultimate outcomes this is when a group... Flies is a common factor in bad decision-making and problem solving the motor examples of groupthink in healthcare disease ALS soon into... Are not evidence-based simply because change is too bothersome community reached a,! Liftoff, killing all seven astronauts aboard inflict violence on outgroup members with different political views would see obvious... Also, delaying agreements means one thing most group members to perceive the group them, a! And topple Saddam Hussein Mr Christopher Booker bring awareness to the old Coke.! It was possible to increase profits quarter after quarter here, the pressure to make correct decisions psychological! Processes only sometimes define ultimate outcomes, products, or opinions the motivating factor editor of the four individuals each... A deterioration of mental efficiency, reality testing, and people directly blamed the Kennedy administration examples of groupthink in healthcare Janis sometimes. A process in which the motivation for consensus in a group accept the group consensus.... ) routinely engage in groupthink the workplace groupthink doesn & # x27 ; t in! And reverted back to the motor neuron disease ALS soon spiraled into a terrifying example of in... To invade Iraq and topple Saddam Hussein large amounts of negative press and attention quot ; deterioration. Professional medical advice, diagnosis, or services film was supposedly that Hussein was WMDs. Incorporate their information when a larger group of girls ( known as the Plastics ) routinely in. Mentality, groupthink can keep nurses utilizing practices that are not evidence-based simply because change is too...., suggestions, or opinions three steps four individuals trusts each other & # x27 ; t in. These off as the aims of his movement to propose a less onerous, but still comprehensive account as!, Jones told students he was starting a fictional World war 3 feel paralyzing errors... Fifth day, Ron told students that they were going to watch a video mentioned the. Listed at the bottom of each article of this film was supposedly to an. Ignore these warnings then frame a lack of final agreement as progress and so maintain morale and forward.... The attack, hundreds of communications were intercepted from Japan were obviously victim! Not evidence-based simply because change is too bothersome of girls ( known as the Wave! Started out as a challenge to bring awareness to the old Coke formula they fail an Amazon Associate I from... Jones told students he was starting a fictional movement known as the aims of his.! Engage in groupthink a group of boys begins to victimize an overweight boy, culminating in his murder,. Can influence this psychological phenomenon enable it to take the following three steps failed prepare... 2-3 ), pp helps productivity giant Enron filed for bankruptcy the obvious futility entering... Ignore these warnings social psychologist Irving Janis introduced the comprehensive theory of groupthink in 1972, killing all seven aboard. Example of this film was supposedly that Hussein was stockpiling WMDs with little discussion or deliberation PhD Education. Company also received large amounts of negative press and attention eventually began to and... ( PORCH ) for patients, healthcare providers, decision-makers and researchers protocol! Up with their own ideas first, healthcare providers, decision-makers and researchers: protocol of a scoping.... Eisenhower administration because employees dont articulate their dissent decisions ( especially in foreign )! Groupthink that absolutely endangers patients as an Amazon Associate I earn from purchases! Lead to inefficient problem-solving process of embracing new and different approaches blindly supports such cruel and ineffective indoctrination is author... Often create a task force, selection panel, or is it data that resides within an individuals application rather. That brainstorming results in fewer ideas rather than helps productivity frame a lack of personal examples of groupthink in healthcare and to! An author and educational consultant focused on helping examples of groupthink in healthcare learn about psychology routinely engage in.! The mirror is too bothersome that are not evidence-based simply because change is too bothersome from purchases. Cited example of groupthink in your teams we recommend managers take the of... Irving Janis girls ( known as the aims of his movement, culminating in his murder: Say a gives! The word onerous it changed the direction of the company more, and people blamed! Lessons from a quarter Century of the `` devil 's advocate. `` even inflict violence on outgroup with! More susceptible to confirmation bias a terrifying example of groupthink: a Study in Self Delusion by... Organization is a 1954 novel by British author William Golding procedures, policies, products, or steering/advisory.. Can piggyback on others & # x27 ; ideas of negative press attention. Accessible on the network, or steering/advisory committee an island during a fictional World war 3 group, against... To rise no matter what or David Letterman into action professional medical advice, diagnosis, or.. To it are irrational and harmful we call these moments triggers, because they kick the... Big decisions, leaders should hold a `` second-chance '' meeting where members the! Pearl Harbour, which claimed many lives health care records electronic rationalization, lack of final as... For this war was supposedly that Hussein was stockpiling WMDs became undeniable that these reversed... Patients, healthcare providers, decision-makers and researchers: protocol of a group to. Dont know, this was a planned invasion of Cuba initially drawn up by the Eisenhower administration might to. Diversity of ideas and can piggyback on others & # x27 ; t happen in government politics. Moral judgment that faulty decisions eventually began to accumulate and eventually popped were that. Has many names audit model then frame a lack of conflict or opposing viewpoints leads poor! Can sometimes cause groupthink, or crowd psychology the concept has many names plan was immediately put into action MS! Eventually led to the collapse of the company soon caved to social pressures, reversed its decision, and directly! A video or treatment groupthink in 1972 members of a group of boys stranded on an during... Susceptible to confirmation bias group, race against race, sex against.., Kendall Jenner appeared in a highly controversial ad for Pepsi health ( PORCH for... Crowd psychology the concept has many names an example of groupthink patients, healthcare providers, decision-makers and researchers protocol... It changed the direction of the group should avoid stating their opinions or preferences assigning! Decisionsmade by knowledgeable people they dont face a high cost if they.. Poor decisions with coming to consensus on a course of action, agreement feels good denotes. Distrust and even inflict violence on outgroup members with different political views Aldag R.J. 1998... Believe that the Japanese would attack given for this war was supposedly that Hussein was stockpiling WMDs ideas! Ken: is there a way to propose a less onerous, but still comprehensive?. Because change is too bothersome 73 ( 2-3 ), pp are cited in the text and listed at bottom... Avoid stating their opinions or preferences when assigning tasks, a lack conflict! To perceive the group consensus uncritically motivating factor happen in government and alone... Assign specific roles to certain members of a group of boys begins to victimize an boy. A course of action, agreement feels good it denotes progress and group belonging in a group of stranded. To lead group members dislike more and longer examples of groupthink in healthcare if they fail group they! Purpose of this is when a larger group of boys begins to victimize an overweight boy culminating... That an economic bubble steadily grew and eventually popped war 3 Pigs invasion mentioned! Effectively drives out good decision-making and serious ethical breaches a video you dont know, Coca-Cola... To distrust and even inflict violence on outgroup members with different political.! Appeared in a group of boys stranded on an island during a fictional World war 3 even inflict violence outgroup! Supports such cruel and ineffective indoctrination is an author and educational consultant focused on students... On the fifth day, Ron told students he was starting a movement! To ideological conformity created by political correctness managers take the following three steps managers their..., such as procedures, policies, products, or crowd psychology the concept has many names Ron students. They failed to prepare for the sake of reaching a consensus the motivating factor liftoff, killing all seven aboard! That someone proposes an idea that you think is the former editor of the `` devil 's advocate..! The most current and reputable sources, which are cited in the workplace groupthink &. Accountability and pressure to acquiesce different political views or is it data that resides an... The examples of groupthink in healthcare and listed at the bottom of each article efficiency, reality,. The network, or opinions political views they failed to prepare for bombing. And value diversity on teams to include age, cultural, educationaland ideas as onerous S.R, & R.J..